Well this is weird. So it was working fine but then I switched ots tunes, the fuel trims are still settled at idle but AFR is hanging around 13-15 on pulls again now. Ugh I should've just left it how it was.
But I'm now convinced it's most likely a tune issue. So time to get a new accessport...
UPDATE: So I've been running a "high flow" open filter from Amazon on my Cobb Sri this whole time. I decided today to try putting the old original Cobb filter back into the intake as well as a mesh cover that goes on top of the cone to make it waterproof and it seems to have solved the high fuel...