Would you recommend the quick jack over a two post lift? I’m about to build a house and will have the space to install a two post in my garage which is the way I am leaning but I would be interested to hear your thoughts
I did a lot of research and thinking about this... here's my thoughts.
I think a 2 post lift will always be better, even a short one like the MaxJax. Rolling around on a chair under the car would still be way better than on your back or a creeper.
Portability: Quickjack wins, especially the 12v model if that's something you think you'd ever do.
Garage space: Quickjack you can hang them on or up against the wall, the pump is a small....very small footprint and pretty painless to setup/put away. A 2 post lift will turn a 3 car garage into a 2 car garage or a 2 car into a 1 car etc... unless some sort of weird oversized garage, it's going to take up space/prevent you from fitting an extra car in. The MaxJax advertises easy removal with wheels etc but those things are heavy and you have a bunch of bolts you have to install/remove in concrete...not exactly an easy every day process.
2 post lift usually introduces some unknowns like concrete condition or thickness... in your case with a new house you would know that going in or could make sure it's up to the task.
Price difference between quickjack, maxjax or a more standard height 2 post lift isn't that huge..... if you have a tall ceiling I would definitely be leaning towards a standard 2 post lift, that's going to be hard to beat.
That said the Quickjack with both rubber pads lifts approx 24", which is a great height to roll around on a creeper and still have lots of working room. For almost all jobs this is enough space... a little tight for some, but doable. I did a clutch swap with a friends quickjack years ago (clutch swap on a C5 involves dropping the whole driveshaft, rear cradle as a single piece because transaxle setup).
Quickjack is also super low profile, which makes it really handy for low cars. My process the raise the corvette before involves 3 separate floor jacks.... it was a big pain. The quickjack just slides right under, line up the pads, connect a few quick-connect hoses, lift.
In my experience using full size 2 post lifts...getting my corvette up was still a massive pain. The pads wouldn't fit under the car, so I would have to jack up the front/back, set wood blocks under the tires. And then hope I have the front/back alignment just right so the lift pads can reach the jacking points. If not, then I have to lower the car back down..move forward/back, try again. In a home setup, you could mark the floor or something to make it easy I guess, but still,-- generally a little more tricky.
In my case my house is a rental and I will continue to move around (military), so the portability was the big selling point for me and the compact garage space footprint was a big plus too. We have a 3 car garage and it's nice that we can still park all 3 vehicles inside (frequent hail storms here).
To me it wasn't the ultimate solution.... just a good one that I hope can serve me the next 10+ years. Once I'm in my forever home I would love to have a detached garage/workshop, with space for a full size 2 post lift.